IntroVerseI Put On My Make Up Spray My PerfumeSat On The Front Porch, Waitin' On YouSaid We Would Catch Up Because It Had Been AwhileI Hate To Admit It But My Hands Are ShakingBarely Breathin' Heart Is Racin'Looks Like Feelings Don't Always Change Their MindsBut You Never Called, Never Showed Up Guess Somethings Never ChangeAnd Just Like Living In A Flashback... You Let Me Down AgainHookThat's Why The Past Should Be The PastFar Behind Back Of Mind, Out Of The WayLet The Memories Burn And CrashCause Sittin' Here Looking At The DrivewayIs Just Tearin My Heart Back In HalfLike Nothings Changed Except The Time That's PassedAnd That's Why Good-Bye Should Mean Good-Bye The First TimeInstrumentsVerse 2I Should Know Better I Hate That I Still CryLookin' Like A Fool Here Watchin' For HeadlightsAnd Kickin' Myself For Believin' In You AgainI Bet Your Out Drinkin' With A New Blonde AndTelling Her Whatevers Playin Is Her SongYeah And Helping Her Up Into Your Chevy InsteadEven When You Don't Have Me You Can Still Be The One To Hurt MeIt Must Feel Good To Know That I'm Still Holdin' On To Letting GoOutroOh , The First TimeAnd That's Why The Past Should Be The Past Oh, The First Time